David J.
Danto
Business travel
thoughts in my own, personal opinion
eMail: ddanto@IMCCA.org Follow Industry News: @NJDavidD
Housekeeping And Other Services
“Remember to leave a
daily tip for the housekeeper” I would tell my kids as they became old enough
to stay in hotel rooms by themselves. I
wanted them to appreciate the hard and unglamorous work being done on their
behalf. The old-school method of leaving
a tip only after one checked-out no longer made sense as different housekeepers
may have been taking care of your room on different days.
Unfortunately, my admonition to my
kids clearly wasn’t enough to turn the tide toward treating hotel service employees
better. The generally terrible pay,
working conditions and the pandemic have all combined to create a crisis in the
hospitality industry, threatening a post-pandemic recovery for the space.
Recent
articles have highlighted the problem:
“More than half of
U.S. hospitality workers wouldn’t go back to their old jobs and over a third
aren’t even considering reentering the industry, according to a survey that
underscores hiring challenges for restaurants, bars and hotels. No pay increase or incentive would make these
workers return to their previous workplace, according to a poll of about 13,000
job seekers during the second quarter from Joblist,
an employment-search engine. These former hospitality employees cited wanting
higher pay, a less physically demanding workplace and better benefits, the
survey finds.”
This isn’t new. Bean-counters at many companies in many
industries have been lowering the costs for services for years – which often meant
outsourcing the work to third-party firms that do not pay company equivalent
benefits to their employees. What is new
is the crunch that has been caused by the pandemic and its sunsetting. It has been a life-pause for people across
all sectors and roles, and hospitality service employees are no different. Many employees are reevaluating basic life
questions. ‘Is this where I want to live?’ ‘Is this what I really want to do with
my life?’ ‘Is working for low pay and little benefits worth it when I have to
pay out of my pocket for child-care?’ Etc.
Hospitality firms have had to make a
number of changes to adjust to the current employment crisis. The pandemic gave them cover to experiment
with changes and find out what the public’s reaction would be.
· One obvious
change that I discussed
in a prior blog is that many hotels are no longer automatically performing
daily room cleaning. Management at many
hotel chains have explained that free room cleaning will continue be available –
but only upon-request. Interestingly, a
good number of frequent travelers actually prefer this model for a few
reasons. Not having to ‘tidy-up’ your
room so that a stranger can come in and clean is actually a relief to some, and
others simply prefer knowing no stranger (and his or her germs) have been in
their room. Some properties had already
been offering perks like bonus points or daily dining credits to opt-out of
daily cleaning services even before the pandemic – with others stressing the
positive environmental impact. Expect to
see more room cleaning services as optional in the future.
· Another change
– possibly not as obvious – is hotel food services. Relatively
new companies are popping up that that let hotels outsource their kitchen
and room-services. As a hotel guest you
might be calling the in-house room-service number, but in reality be connected
to an outsourced firm in the neighborhood which then takes your order and
delivers your food to your room (as well as to rooms in a number of other
hotels in the area.) My understanding is
that some of these firms are experiencing explosive growth. Here again, it takes the onus off of the
property to staff service jobs.
· And then
the most obvious change is of course simply the elimination of services and options. We’re seeing this across the board at many
properties. For one example, many low-end
chains that always offered a hot breakfast and pivoted to “grab and go” bags
during the pandemic have not moved
back to the old model – at least not yet.
For another example, we can look to the Las Vegas market to see what has
happened to the All You Can Eat
buffet. Often set-up as a pull-in and/or
loss-leader, all of them closed for health reasons during the pandemic. Some tried to switch to a waiter service
model from a self-service model, but that didn’t last long. Now, as Vegas reopens, not all of the AYCE options have
reopened…or are planning to. Some of
this may be due to the high demand for post-pandemic Vegas travel (why have a loss-leader if one is not needed.) However, I’m sure the lack of available,
interested low-wage employees is having an effect there as well.
One has to acknowledge that this is
a very fluid situation. The COVID-19
variants (and the COVidiots who aren’t getting vaccinated)
may still have a significant impact on how rapidly business travel gets back to
normal. In addition, the push and pull
of ‘how cheaply
you can make the pizza’ has always taken place in travel related
industries. Hospitality firms may find
that they take away one too many benefits for travelers to tolerate. The advice for today however is to remember
everything is different now than it was pre-pandemic. Assume nothing, call the properties where you’re
planning to stay to ask specifically what has changed, and make informed
decisions about your travel plans.
This article was written by David Danto and contains solely his own, personal
opinions.
All image and links provided above as reference under
prevailing fair use statutes.
++++++++
As always, feel free to write and comment, question or
disagree. Hearing from the traveling
community is always a highlight for me.
Thanks!